BuckeyeRoofPros
Article

Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Roofer

Don't hire a roofer without asking these essential questions first. Cover licensing, warranties, materials, timelines, and payment terms to protect your investment.

Buckeye Roof Pros Team
Published Mar 28, 2026 · Updated Nov 8, 2026

Are You Licensed and Insured?

Start here, always. A legitimate roofer will have both a contractor's license (if your state requires one) and current insurance coverage.[1] You're not just checking boxes — you're protecting yourself from liability if someone gets hurt on your property.

Ask to see proof of both general liability insurance and workers' compensation coverage. Write down the policy numbers and call the insurance company directly to verify they're active. Some contractors will show you expired certificates or policies that don't actually cover roofing work.

You want current coverage that specifically mentions roofing operations, not a general handyman policy.

If a roofer hesitates or says "insurance is expensive," walk away. That's not your problem to subsidize, and it becomes your nightmare if an uninsured worker falls off your roof.

Pro Tip: Always verify insurance directly with the carrier. Certificates can be forged or expired. A 60-second phone call to the insurance company protects you from thousands in potential liability if something goes wrong during your roof installation.

How Long Have You Been in Business?

Experience matters when someone's tearing apart your home's primary weather barrier. A company that's been around for 10+ years has survived economic downturns, warranty claims, and the occasional angry customer.[3] They've also developed relationships with suppliers and trained crews who know what they're doing.

Ask for a permanent business address and phone number.[3] A P.O. box and a cell phone aren't always red flags — plenty of small operations run lean — but you want evidence they're not planning to disappear after depositing your check. Search their business name with your state's Secretary of State office.

Legitimate companies are registered entities, not just a guy with a truck.

Newer companies can do excellent work, but they come with higher risk. If you're considering a contractor with less than three years in business, make sure their insurance limits are higher and their references are stellar.

Can You Provide References from Recent Projects?

Anyone can claim they do great work. References prove it.

Ask for at least three customers from the past six months whose projects were similar to yours in size and scope.[1] When you call references, don't just ask if they're happy. Ask specific questions: Did the crew show up on time? How did they handle unexpected problems? Was the cleanup thorough? Did the project stay on budget?

One homeowner's crew discovered four layers of old shingles during tear-off — a surprise that could've derailed everything — but handled it professionally and explained the additional work clearly. That's the kind of real-world problem-solving you want to hear about.

If a roofer says "all our customers are happy, but we can't share names because of privacy," that's nonsense. Satisfied customers are usually happy to take a quick call, especially if it helps someone avoid a bad contractor.

Questions to Ask References:

  • Did the crew arrive on time each day?
  • How did they handle unexpected problems or additional costs?
  • Was the job site kept clean and safe?
  • Did the final cost match the estimate?
  • Would you hire this roofer again?
  • How long did the project actually take vs. what was promised?

What's Your Experience with My Roofing Material?

Not all roofers work with all materials equally well. A crew that installs asphalt shingles all day might struggle with metal roofing or tile.[2]

If you're replacing a specialty roof — slate, cedar shake, standing seam metal — you need someone who's done dozens of these installations, not someone learning on your dime.

Ask how many jobs they've completed with your specific material in the past year. Request photos of recent work. Better yet, ask if you can drive by a completed project to see the quality firsthand. A confident roofer will have no problem showing you their work.

Materials matter beyond aesthetics too. Different products have different installation requirements, flashing details, and ventilation needs. A roofer who understands the engineering behind your roofing system — not just how to nail shingles in straight lines — will spot and prevent problems before they become leaks.

What Does Your Warranty Cover?

This is where many homeowners get burned. Every roof comes with two warranties: one from the manufacturer covering material defects, and one from the contractor covering installation workmanship.[1]

They're not the same thing, and you need both explained clearly.

The manufacturer's warranty is only as good as the installation. Most material warranties are voided if the roof isn't installed according to the manufacturer's specifications. Ask if the contractor is certified by the manufacturer to install their products. Certified installers often provide enhanced warranties that cover both materials and labor.

The workmanship warranty covers installation mistakes — leaks from improper flashing, shingles that blow off because they weren't fastened correctly, ventilation problems. Ask how long this warranty lasts and what it covers. A "lifetime" warranty that only covers materials for the first five years isn't worth the paper it's printed on.

Get the warranty terms in writing before you sign anything.

Warranty Type What It Covers Typical Duration Who Honors It
Manufacturer Material Defective shingles, premature material failure 20-50 years (prorated) Roofing material manufacturer
Contractor Workmanship Installation errors, leaks, improper flashing 1-10 years The roofing contractor
Enhanced/Certified Both materials AND labor 25-50 years (non-prorated) Manufacturer through certified installer

Will You Provide a Detailed Written Estimate?

A legitimate estimate should read like a construction plan, not a napkin sketch.[3] You want to see the scope of work broken down clearly: tear-off and disposal of old materials, deck repairs if needed, ice and water shield installation, underlayment type, shingle brand and model, flashing details, ridge vents, cleanup procedures, and timeline.

The estimate should also specify payment terms. Be wary of any contractor who wants full payment upfront or demands cash. A standard payment structure is usually one-third down, one-third when materials arrive, and the final third upon completion and your satisfaction. Some contractors work on a 50/50 split.

Both are reasonable, but 100% upfront is not.

If two estimates vary wildly in price, the difference is usually in what's included — or what's being cut. The lowest bid might skip crucial steps like ice and water shield in valleys, or plan to reuse rusty flashing instead of replacing it. Price matters, but scope matters more.

How Will You Handle Unexpected Issues?

Every roof replacement reveals surprises. Rotten decking hidden under old shingles. Improperly installed chimneys. Ventilation that doesn't meet code.

The question isn't whether you'll encounter problems — it's how the contractor will handle them.

Ask what happens if they discover damaged decking or structural issues during tear-off. Will they call you before proceeding with repairs? How do they calculate pricing for additional work? Some contractors include a contingency allowance in their estimate for minor repairs. Others charge strictly time-and-materials for anything beyond the original scope.

The best roofers document problems with photos and explain your options before moving forward. They don't call you at 4 PM saying they've already replaced $2,000 worth of decking and you owe them more money. Multiple homeowners mention appreciating crews that caught and explained issues early, even when it meant additional cost, because it prevented bigger problems later.

What's Your Cleanup and Project Timeline?

A roof replacement is loud, messy, and disruptive. You deserve to know exactly what you're in for.

Ask how long the project will take from start to finish — not best-case scenario, but realistic timeline including potential weather delays.[2] Discuss cleanup procedures in detail. Will they use tarps to protect landscaping? How often will they sweep the yard and driveway for nails? Do they use magnetic rollers to pick up metal debris, or do they just eyeball it?

A roof typically sheds thousands of nails during tear-off. One stray nail in your tire or your kid's foot makes even a beautiful roof feel like a disaster.

Ask about site management too. Where will the dumpster go? Will they need to park work vehicles in your driveway? What happens if it rains mid-project? The crew's professionalism during installation matters as much as their technical skill — you're going to live with these people around your home for several days.

Will You Pull the Necessary Permits?

Most jurisdictions require permits for roof replacements, and the contractor should handle this — not you.[1] Permits aren't bureaucratic busywork. They ensure the work gets inspected by a third party who verifies it meets building codes.

If a roofer suggests skipping permits to "save money" or "speed things up," you're talking to someone who cuts corners.

Unpermitted work can complicate insurance claims, tank your home's resale value, and leave you liable for bringing everything up to code later — often at your expense, years after the roofer has moved on.

Ask who's responsible for scheduling inspections and what happens if the work doesn't pass. A quality contractor expects to pass inspection on the first try and will make any corrections at no additional cost if something gets flagged.

How Do You Handle Communication During the Project?

This seems minor until you're sitting at work wondering if the crew showed up, or you come home to find half your roof exposed with storms rolling in and nobody answering their phone.

Establish communication expectations upfront.

Who's your point of contact if problems arise? Will the owner be on-site, or will you work with a foreman? How quickly can you expect responses to calls or texts? Some contractors provide daily end-of-day updates with photos. Others go radio silent until the job's done.

Several homeowners call out the value of working with roofers who kept them informed throughout the process. When unexpected issues arose — like discovering multiple layers of old shingles that needed removal — clear communication turned a potential conflict into a manageable adjustment.

You want that kind of transparency.

What Payment Methods Do You Accept?

This reveals more than you'd think. Established contractors accept multiple payment methods — checks, credit cards, financing options.

A roofer who only takes cash or money orders is either trying to dodge taxes or doesn't have the business infrastructure to process legitimate payments.

Understand the payment schedule and get it in writing. Never pay the full amount before work is complete and you've verified quality. If a contractor pressures you to pay in full upfront because "materials are expensive" or "we need to secure your spot," that's a red flag. Material suppliers extend credit to legitimate roofing companies.

Your money shouldn't be their credit line.

Ask about lien waivers too. These documents confirm that the contractor has paid their suppliers and subcontractors. Without them, you could pay your roofer in full and still have a materials supplier place a lien on your home if the contractor never paid them. It happens more often than you'd think.

Do You Subcontract the Work?

Some roofing companies use their own crews. Others subcontract everything to independent teams. Neither approach is automatically better, but you need to know who's hammering nails on your roof.

If they use subcontractors, ask about oversight. Does the company supervise the work? Are the subs insured separately? How long has the company worked with these crews?

A general contractor who hires whoever's available that week has less quality control than one who works with the same trusted teams repeatedly.

The professionalism and focus of the crew matters enormously. You want workers who take pride in their craft, not day laborers who've never roofed before. Homeowners consistently mention appreciating crews that were courteous, careful, and clearly knew what they were doing — the kind of teams you only get from companies that invest in training and retention.

What Happens If I'm Not Satisfied?

Ask this question directly and watch the response. A confident contractor will explain their process for addressing concerns, usually offering to revisit any issues and make corrections until you're satisfied.

Get their complaint resolution process in writing. What's the timeline for addressing problems? Who inspects the work before final payment?

Some contractors include a final walkthrough in their contract where you jointly inspect the roof and note any concerns before the last check clears.

Understand what happens if problems emerge after the job is complete. A few homeowners mention needing multiple return trips to fix leaks that weren't addressed correctly initially. A contractor with a solid warranty and clear communication handled these callbacks professionally. One who disappears or makes excuses leaves you with an expensive problem and no recourse.

The best protection is choosing carefully on the front end. These questions filter out the contractors who won't be around to honor their promises from the ones who will.

  1. National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA). "NRCA Guidelines for Selecting a Roofing Contractor." https://www.nrca.net/resources/guidelines-for-selecting-a-roofing-contractor. Accessed March 29, 2026.
  2. Roofing Contractor Magazine. "Steep Slope Roofing Contractor." https://www.roofingcontractor.com/articles/96623-steep-slope-roofing-contractor. Accessed March 29, 2026.
  3. Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA). "Ten Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Roofing Contractor." https://www.asphaltroofing.org/ten-questions-to-ask-before-hiring-a-roofing-contractor/. Accessed March 29, 2026.

Ready to get started?

Find Trusted Roofers in Ohio

Compare top-rated roofers across Ohio — read reviews and get free estimates.

Browse Roofers